As Bruxas Amish
Voltar- Nicole RodenburgConor
- Hayley PalmaerEsther
- Kaylyn ScardefieldIva
Evangeline YoungRuthie
Michelle YoungKatie Ann- Caleb CarlsonIsaac
- Troy CurtisDave
Chase ConnerWill
Amanda Jane SternA.J.
David WinningThe Bishop- Mieke StapelbergSoloma
- Clare BuckinghamAbigail
- Andrea DemarcoDeceased Grandmother
- Luke TourtelliotteBaby
- Asia ManuelDiner Waitress
- Clayton BrownPolice Officer #1
- Antoine SmithPolice Officer #2
- Derek RobertsEMT #1
- Montgomery LyonsEMT #2
- Casey QuakeEMT #3
- Josh G. AllegraHorse and Buggy Driver
- Randy FranklinFootman
- Natalie VogelAmish Market Mother
- Neil RosenAmish Market Son
- Leila GodbotAmish Market Daughter
- Jaret J. LennettAmish Market Man
- Melissa LopezDiner Patron Couple
- Zachary WoodstockDiner Patron Couple
- Ryan BartoDiner Patron Teen #1
- Adrianna DellavalleDiner Patron Teen #2
- Anne SupinaDiner Patron Teen #3
Alex CerdeiraDiner Patron Family- Ashlyn WhiteDiner Patron Family