Scare Me
Voltar- DeMarr D. WrightBarry
Taylor KilgoreSandy
Mark JusticeDonnie
Caslin RoseKelly- Brandon McClenahamRoger
Nicole UngerAlex- Thomas FiscoCooper
Tommie VegasRanger Rachel- Gus LangleyRanger Sean
Ben StobberJohn Dougherty
Adriane McLeanJessica Watson- Michael O'NealPhineas Parsons
- Anthony AveryOfficer Summers
- Joseph BenShimonBrandon
- Stu ChaikenOfficer Miller
- Alexander ColomHenry Capers
Jed CurtisJacob Townsend- Miranda DudleyReceptionist (segment "I for an Eye")
- Zander GarciaJack Reed
Sonia GascónLizzy
Morlon GreenwoodDante- Danny LathamRob Reed
Raul LimonTim's New Friend
Drew MarvickJohn Quaid- Roland MatthewsSergeant Beck
- Meghan MooreLaura Reed
- Michael James NuellsTim
- Tamara PorterSamantha
- Eric SharpeRandy La Salle
Amber StrauserHeather Powers
Bri Ana WagnerMichelle
John WardRobert the Waiter- Parker Lemon MarvickJaney Quaid
- Stefanie ClenanceTim's New Friend
- Degan MarvickJoey Quaid
- Sablique Von LuxHigh Priestess (segment "I for an Eye")
Lauren FogleWitch (segment "I for an Eye")